
| Summaries of the latest research concerning fish oils and heart health |
|
Fish oils in treatment of heart failure BRESCIA, ITALY. Heart failure, also known as congestive heart failure, is generally defined as the inability of the heart to supply sufficient blood flow to meet the needs of the body. Common causes of heart failure include heart attack(s), ischemic heart disease (coronary artery disease), hypertension, valvular heart disease, and cardiomyopathy (enlarged or weakened heart muscle). Heart failure is most often associated with reduced blood flow to the heart (ischemic), but can also be due to an enlarged and weakened left ventricle (non-ischemic dilated cardiomyopathy). A landmark study (GISSI-HF) reported in 2008 found evidence that supplementation with 1 gram/day of fish oil significantly reduced mortality and hospitalization in patients with heart failure (either ischemic or non-ischemic). A group of researchers from the University of Brescia report that fish oil supplementation is highly effective in reversing non-ischemic dilated cardiomyopathy (NICM). Their clinical trial involved 133 patients with chronic NICM and left ventricular systolic dysfunction (defined as a left ventricular ejection fraction of less than 45%) who were enrolled in 2007-2008. The average age of the patients was 63 years and 10% were women. Average time since diagnosis was 4 years and the average NYHA functional class was 1.85. The New York Heart Association (NYHA) classification defines severity of heart failure as class I to IV with class IV being the most severe. All patients were on a drug regimen consisting of a beta-blocker, an ACE inhibitor or angiotensin receptor blocker, and furosemide (a diuretic). At the start of the trial, participants were randomly assigned to a placebo group or a fish oil group. The placebo group received a 1-gram capsule of olive oil a day for the duration of the trial. The fish oil group received 5 fish oil capsules a day for the first month (providing 1625 mg/day of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and 2700 mg/day of DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) in the form of ethyl esters) and then 2 capsules a day for the remaining 11 months of the trial (providing 650 mg/day of EPA and 1080 mg/day of DHA). At the end of the 12-month trial, the researchers observed the following statistically significant differences between the two groups.
At the conclusion of the trial, a significant decrease in inflammatory biomarkers was also noticed in the fish oil group, whereas the level of inflammatory biomarkers had risen significantly in the placebo group. Furthermore, whereas 24% of the placebo group required an increase in their daily furosemide dosage, 39% of the fish oil group were able to reduce their dosage. Overall, among study participants randomized to fish oil, 27% showed improvement in myocardial function, whereas 30% of the placebo group showed a decline from their baseline condition.
The researchers conclude that fish oil supplementation improves left ventricular systolic function and heart function
in general, and may reduce hospitalization for heart failure-related complications.
Bypass patients benefit from fish oil Following CABG, 930 of the study participants were assigned to receive fish oil supplementation at the discretion of their cardiologist. NOTE: Patients receiving fish oils were more likely to have a higher prevalence of diabetes and were significantly more likely to have a history of heart attack and/or prior percutaneous coronary intervention. The remaining 1170 patients did not receive fish oils but the majority of all patients in both groups received aspirin (88%), ACE inhibitor or angiotensin receptor blocker (75%), and/or beta-blocker (78%). The prescribed dose of fish oil provided 580 mg/day of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and 1140 mg/day of DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) both in the form of ethyl esters. After a median follow-up of 2.5 years, the Italian researchers concluded that fish oil supplementation was associated with the following benefits:
The lower mortality was particularly significant among patients with poor left ventricular ejection fraction (64%
reduced risk of dying), but only marginal among patients with good ejection fraction (11% reduced risk of dying).
The researchers conclude that fish oil supplementation should be an integral part of standard medical therapy
following CABG.
Fish oils and PVCs Their study involved 260 MI patients who were enrolled in the study within 72 hours of their heart attack. Most of the study participants were male (62.9%) with an age ranging between 27 and 86 years, and an average left ventricular ejection fraction of 52%. Most of the patients (88.5%) were taking beta-blockers at the time of their assessment and, not surprisingly, most had one or more comorbid conditions. Thus, 59% had hypertension, 41% diabetes, 12% chronic obstructive pulmonary disorder (COPD), and 7% congestive heart failure. Seventy-three percent had a history of smoking and 57% were current smokers.
All participants completed the Harvard food-frequency questionnaire to determine their average dietary intake of
omega-3 fatty acids during the year preceding their MI. They also underwent 24-hour Holter monitoring either
during or immediately following their hospital stay. Evaluation of the data collected showed a clear inverse
relationship between the intake of omega-3 fatty acids and the number of daily PVCs (including couplets, triplets,
bigeminy, etc). Based on a daily energy intake of 1000 kcal, the researchers observed that an average daily intake
of 0.6 gram of n-3 fatty acids was associated with 450 PVCs/day, while an intake of 0.9 gram/day was associated
with only 235 PVCs/day. They estimate that a 1-gram/day increase in the intake of EPA + DHA could reduce the
number of PVCs by as much as 800/day. ALA reduced PVCs in a similar fashion, but although it has been shown
to help prevent CHD, there is no evidence that it reduces SCD. The researchers conclude that future randomized,
controlled trials are needed to investigate whether fish oil supplementation during hospitalization for MI will reduce
the number of sudden cardiac deaths.
Net benefit of fish consumption Thus, it is not surprising that health authorities promote the frequent consumption of fish with the American Heart Association (AHA) specifically recommending that healthy people eat fish at least twice a week. The AHA also recommends that patients with heart disease consume at least 1000 mg of EPA + DHA every day. Unfortunately, it is becoming more and more apparent that fish consumption is not always beneficial. Gary Ginsberg and Brian Toal from the Connecticut Department of Public Health point out that many fish are now heavily contaminated with methylmercury, a highly toxic compound with profound deleterious effects on both the cardiovascular and nervous system. Many researchers have studied these adverse effects and a consensus has been arrived at as to just what amounts of methylmercury are likely to produce serious consequences. Similarly, many studies have been done to determine the minimum daily intakes of EPA + DHA needed to obtain significant benefits. The two Connecticut researchers have combined these findings into two models aimed at predicting the net health benefits of consuming particular fish and seafood. One model is concerned with determining the net benefit for adult men and women (in regard to heart disease), the other with determining the net benefits for pregnant women and infants.
The researchers looked at 13 fish and seafood specimens available fresh in Connecticut and 3 varieties of canned
tuna. They found that it was safe for adults to consume unlimited amounts of tilapia, pollack, flounder, cod, shrimp,
trout, herring, canned light tuna, and Atlantic salmon, although they warn that farmed salmon may not be desirable
due to concerns about its possible content of carcinogens. Swordfish and shark should be totally avoided and tuna
steak should be eaten no more than once a week. Canned white tuna (Albacore), halibut, sea bass, and lobster
can safely be eaten twice a week. Their recommendations for pregnant women and infants are somewhat more
restrictive in that consumption of canned light tuna and cod should be limited to twice a week and consumption of
canned white tuna, tuna steak, halibut, sea bass and lobster should be limited to once a week.
Fish oils and heart rate variability Other important measures derived from HRV analysis include the Poincare ratio and the short-term fractal scaling exponent (DFA1) which are related to sinoatrial node firing patterns. A low Poincare ratio and/or a high DFA1 correspond to a less erratic heart beat (more normal sinoatrial firing). A low heart rate variability has been implicated in sudden cardiac death, ventricular fibrillation, angina, heart attack, atherosclerosis, and other heart-related problems. HRV analysis has been used extensively in the study of atrial fibrillation. LAF episodes can be divided into two groups – those that are preceded by an increase in LF power and a decrease in HF power consistent with an increase in sympathetic (adrenergic) tone, and those that are preceded by a decrease in LF power and an increase in HF power consistent with an increase in parasympathetic (vagal) tone. The changes in HRV are apparent at least 5 minutes before the actual episode. A team of researchers from Harvard Medical School, Washington University School of Medicine, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, and the University of Washington now reports that the consumption of oily fish and fish oils strongly influences HRV. Their study involved 4465 older men and women (average age at enrolment of 72 years) who were enrolled in 1989-1990 and then followed for 10 years. At enrolment all participants were given a resting 12-lead ECG or a 24-hour Holter monitor recording and information about their intake of fish and fish oils over the past year was obtained. The researchers observed a significant correlation between the intake of broiled or baked fish (especially tuna) and HRV. They also observed a strong correlation between plasma levels of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and HRV. Study participants with a high broiled/baked fish intake experienced a greater HRV (higher SDNN) than those with a lower intake. They also showed lower LF power (lower adrenergic stimulation of the ANS) and higher HF power (increased vagal dominance of the ANS), thus resulting in a lower LF/HF ratio, again suggestive of vagal dominance. High fish consumers also had a lower Poincare ratio and a higher DFA1 indicating a more stable sinoatrial firing pattern. These correlations were also evident when comparing HRV variables with the intake of EPA + DHA. The researchers did not observe any correlation between HRV and the intake of fried (non-fatty) fish.
During the follow-up period, 542 deaths occurred related to cardiovascular causes (1.1%/person-year). The
researchers found that high values of SDNN and DFA1 were associated with a 1.1% and 8.4% respectively reduced
risk of cardiovascular death, while a low Poincare ratio was associated with a 5.9% risk reduction. They conclude
that an increased intake of oily fish (or EPA + DHA) have significant beneficial effects on parameters influencing
HRV, specifically an increase in vagal tone, modulation of adrenergic-mediated baroreceptor activity, and improved
sinoatrial node function. NOTE: The average daily intake of EPA + DHA ranged from 47 mg to 927 mg.
Association between low EPA levels and heart disease
The study included 291 patients who had been referred for elective coronary angiography because of suspected
CAD. The researchers observed a significant correlation between LPA2 concentration and severity of CAD with
patients with 3-vessel disease (50% or greater narrowing [stenosis] of 3 major coronary arteries) having the highest
LPA2 level. They also found that a high LPA2 level was significantly associated with a low level of EPA. The
researchers speculate that the mechanism(s) by which fish oils (EPA+DHA) protect against CAD may include an
interaction with LPA2. More specifically, fish oils may reduce the concentration of small dense LDL particles, which
are the primary carriers of LPA2. Fish oils also have proven antiinflammatory effects which, through an inhibitory
effect of monocyte and macrophage reactivity, may reduce circulating levels of LPA2.
Fish oil incorporation in myocardial tissue Australian researchers recently reported some very exciting findings regarding the actual mechanism and effectiveness of increasing the EPA + DHA content of myocytes and erythrocytes (red blood cells) by daily supplementation with fish oil. Their study involved 60 patients scheduled for on-pump bypass surgery and/or valve repair. The patients were divided into six groups of 10 patients and received supplements as follows:
Blood samples and biopsy specimens from the right atrium were taken during surgery. The samples were analyzed for fatty acid content and the following results obtained:
The above results lead to the following observations:
The researchers conclude that daily supplementation with 6 grams of EPA + DHA rapidly increases the EPA + DHA
content of cardiomyocyte phospholipid membranes at the expense of a decrease in arachidonic acid level. They
point out that these optimal rates of EPA + DHA incorporation are not likely to be matched at lower doses of fish oil.
They also make the interesting suggestion that high-dose fish oil supplementation could be beneficial for patients
recovering from a heart attack.
Fish oil reduces heart disease risk in arthritis patients A team from the Royal Adelaide Hospital investigated the effects of fish oil supplementation on several cardiovascular risk factors. They recruited 31 early RA patients all taking drug treatment for the condition, of whom 18 also chose to take fish oil. The dose was considered by the researchers to be sufficiently high to have an anti-inflammatory action. After three years of supplementation, data from the patients who did not take fish oil was compared with data from those did and reached a level of EPA greater than 5 per cent of total plasma fatty acids. Arachidonic acid, an omega 6 fatty acid which competes with omega 3 FAs, was lower in participants who reached the required level of EPA. It was 30 per cent lower in platelets and 40 per cent lower in peripheral blood cells. Serum thromboxane B2, a cardiovascular risk factor, was 35 per cent lower. Prostaglandin E2, a compound which RA drug treatment seeks to reduce, was 41 per cent lower.
Fish oil was also linked to positive changes in blood lipids, and a greater rate of remission after the 3 years - 72 per cent compared to 31 per cent in the non-fish oil group. The authors conclude that fish oil reduces cardiovascular risk in RA patients, and that this takes places via several biological pathways. They suggest that fish oil could potentially replace drug treatment for many RA patients. In this study, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug use was reduced by 75 per cent in the fish oil group between the start and finish of the study, compared with 37 per cent in the non-fish oil group. Added to which, RA drugs may themselves contribute to cardiovascular risk. Fish oil is a cheaper, safer treatment option and could also serve as a preventative measure against RA, the authors conclude.
Review confirms fish oil benefits in prevention of heart disease They selected 15 studies on secondary prevention and 33 on primary prevention of cardiovascular disease, each lasting for a minimum of one year. Most of the studies on secondary prevention found that fish oil significantly reduced all-cause mortality, heart attack, cardiac and sudden death, and stroke. For primary prevention, most studies found fish consumption was linked with lower rates of all-cause mortality and cardiac events, but the evidence for stroke prevention was less strong. The benefits of ALA consumption for reducing cardiovascular risk were not convincing. The researchers believe these results support the importance of an adequate intake of n-3 FAs, either through fish or supplements or both, for reducing the risk of all-cause mortality, cardiac and sudden death, and possibly stroke. They add that the benefits are clearer for secondary prevention, and that very few adverse effects were seen.
In an editorial, experts from Columbia University point out that questions remain over the optimum n-3 to n-6 FA ratio, the best surrogate measure of n-3 FA levels, and the relative benefits of EPA and DHA. The biological pathways of the preventive effects of n-3 FAs on cardiovascular health must also be better explained, as must the crucial periods in the lifespan for adequate n-3 FA intakes. They conclude by asking whether intake recommendations for EPA and DHA can now be set, and refer to the American Heart Association guidelines - an intake of about 1 gram of EPA/DHA per day for patients with cardiovascular disease, and about half that (equaling 2 servings of oily fish per week) for those without. Public health initiatives are needed to increase EPA and DHA intakes, they write.
Fish and fish oils help protect the heart
The authors state that, compared with a modest fish intake of once a week or about 20 g/d, a higher intake is linked to a substantially reduced risk of coronary heart disease, primarily heart attack or nonfatal cardiac events, among middle-aged persons. They add that the lowest fifth of fish intake in this study corresponds to the middle fifth in Western studies. They conclude that a high intake of fish can further reduce the risk of initial coronary heart disease events. The team also measured intake of n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (present in fish and certain other foods) and found a strong association with lower risk of heart attack (reduced by 65 per cent) and nonfatal coronary events (reduced by 67 per cent). They suggest several possible underlying mechanisms, such as a reduction in platelet aggregation and increased levels of vasodilators, which cause blood vessels to dilate. Furthermore, n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids may reduce the number of inflammatory cells and help prevent atherosclerosis - hardening of the arteries. They may also reduce insulin resistance, blood fats, blood-clotting cells and blood pressure.
Benefits of fish oils for prevention of heart disease Now, researchers from Emory University School of Medicine have reviewed the data from randomized controlled clinical trials on n-3 PUFAs and CHD. The studies were divided into those using plant-based n-3 PUFAs (alpha-linolenic acid, ALA), fish-based n-3 PUFAs (eicosapentaenoic acid, EPA, and docosahexaenoic acid, DHA), and fish consumption in the diet. Fourteen randomized clinical trials were included in the review, six of which were of fish oil, including one large trial of 10,000 participants. The researchers report a clear trend suggesting that there are important differences in CHD outcomes when using fish-based EPA or DHA compared with plant-based ALA. Most of the fish oil trials suggest a significant reduction in total mortality and CHD deaths and a possible strong antiarrhythmic effect. The dietary fish trials also suggest a reduction in mortality and reduced arrhythmia, supporting the theory that fish-based n-3 PUFAs may impart their cardioprotective effect by acting as an antiarrhythmic agent. They may do so by stabilizing the electrical activity of heart muscle cells or by decreasing the heart rate. The trials of ALA supplements and ALA-enriched diets, including walnut, soybean, or flaxseed oil, were less reliable, but showed possible benefits in reducing mortality.
The review concludes that the evidence suggests a role for fish oil (EPA, DHA) or fish in secondary prevention, as clinical trial data demonstrate a significant reduction in total mortality, coronary heart disease death, and sudden death. However the data on ALA is limited by studies of limited quality. Several previous studies have suggested that n-3 PUFAs reduce heart attack risk through benefiting endothelial function (cells of blood vessel walls), reducing inflammation, and the risk of thrombosis (blood clotting). The American Heart Association has published guidelines for patients with CHD recommending a consumption of fish and fish oil, totaling 1g/day of EPA and DHA.
Omega-3 fatty acids may reduce mortality from heart disease A combined analysis showed that treatment with omega-3 fatty acids (fish and flaxseed oils) reduced overall risk of death by 23 per cent as compared to placebo. Treatment with statin drugs, on the other hand, only reduced overall mortality by 13 per cent as compared to placebo. Fibrates (gemfibrozil, fenofibrates), bile acid resins (cholestyramine, colestipol), niacin and dietary interventions showed no statistically significant differences from results obtained in the control groups. Deaths from cardiovascular causes were 32 per cent lower in the omega-3 fatty acid groups than in control (placebo) groups. Statin drugs reduced cardiovascular mortality by 22 per cent and the use of bile acid resins were associated with a 30 per cent decline in cardiovascular mortality. When death from non-cardiovascular causes was considered, none of the interventions were significantly linked to reduced mortality. However, fibrates were linked to a 13 per cent increased risk of death.
The effects on mortality tended to be more pronounced in longer studies and those with patients whose cardiovascular disease was well established, say the authors. Regarding n-3 fatty acids, they speculate that the reduction in mortality risk does not occur through a reduction in cholesterol but by other means, possibly antiarrhythmic, antithrombotic or anti-inflammatory effects. The trials of n-3 fatty acids used different dietary and supplement sources; nevertheless, the authors conclude that this study adds to the positive evidence for n-3 fatty acids. They suggest that further trials be carried out to examine the effects of combined treatment with n-3 fatty acids and statins.
DHA helps prevent heart disease in children A team of American and Austrian cardiologists has evaluated the effect of supplementation with DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) on FMD in children with hypercholesterolemia or hyperlipidemia. Their double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trial involved 20 patients (ages 9-19 years) who were assigned to receive 1.2 grams/day of DHA or a placebo for 2 separate 6-week periods. All participants followed the National Cholesterol Education Program Step II diet throughout the study. At baseline the average FMD was 5.9%. Just following the NCEP-II diet increased the FMD to 6.3%, while adding 1.2 grams/day of DHA increased it by 34% to a normal level of 7.9%. The average total cholesterol level was 282 mg/dL at baseline and this increased to 297 mg/dL after 6 weeks of DHA supplementation. However, triglycerides decreased from an average of 139 mg/dL to 119 mg/dL (a drop of 14%). Very low-density lipoprotein concentration also decreased by about 23%, while both low-density lipoprotein and high-density lipoprotein increased by 8% and 6% respectively.
The researchers speculate that the change in cholesterol concentrations may represent a beneficial shift in lipoprotein particle size from the atherogenic, small, dense type to the less atherogenic, large, buoyant type. They also suggest that the observed increase in FMD may be due to increased availability of nitric oxide (NO), which promotes dilation of blood vessels resulting in improved flow. They conclude that supplementation with DHA has the potential to delay early coronary atherosclerosis in hyperlipidemic children.
Review supports benefits of omega-3 fatty acids for prevention of heart disease Now, researchers from Emory University School of Medicine have reviewed the data from randomized controlled clinical trials on n-3 PUFAs and CHD. The studies were divided into those using plant-based n-3 PUFAs (alpha-linolenic acid, ALA), fish-based n-3 PUFAs (eicosapentaenoic acid, EPA, and docosahexaenoic acid, DHA), and fish consumption in the diet. Fourteen randomized clinical trials were included in the review, six of which were of fish oil, including one large trial of 10,000 participants. The researchers report a clear trend suggesting that there are important differences in CHD outcomes when using fish-based EPA or DHA compared with plant-based ALA. Most of the fish oil trials suggest a significant reduction in total mortality and CHD deaths and a possible strong antiarrhythmic effect. The dietary fish trials also suggest a reduction in mortality and reduced arrhythmia, supporting the theory that fish-based n-3 PUFAs may impart their cardioprotective effect by acting as an antiarrhythmic agent. They may do so by stabilizing the electrical activity of heart muscle cells or by decreasing the heart rate. The trials of ALA supplements and ALA-enriched diets, including walnut, soybean, or flaxseed oil, were less reliable, but showed possible benefits in reducing mortality.
The review concludes that the evidence suggests a role for fish oil (EPA, DHA) or fish in
secondary prevention, as clinical trial data demonstrate a significant reduction in total mortality,
coronary heart disease death, and sudden death. However the data on ALA is limited by studies
of limited quality. Several previous studies have suggested that n-3 PUFAs reduce heart attack
risk through benefiting endothelial function (cells of blood vessel walls), reducing inflammation,
and the risk of thrombosis (blood clotting). The American Heart Association has published
guidelines for patients with CHD recommending a consumption of fish and fish oil, totaling 1g/day
of EPA and DHA.
Omega-3 fatty acids may reduce mortality from heart disease To determine the overall benefit of these agents on mortality, a group of researchers at the University Hospital Basel reviewed the most reliable published studies. They searched for good- quality randomized, controlled trials between 1965 and 2003, comparing lipid-lowering drugs or dietary interventions against placebo. This process left them with 35 trials on statins, 17 on fibrates, 8 on resins, 2 on niacin, 14 on omega-3 fatty acids, and 17 on other dietary interventions. This produced a total of 137,140 participants in treatments groups and 138,976 in control groups. A combined analysis showed that treatment with omega-3 fatty acids (fish and flaxseed oils) reduced overall risk of death by 23 per cent as compared to placebo. Treatment with statin drugs, on the other hand, only reduced overall mortality by 13 per cent as compared to placebo. Fibrates (gemfibrozil, fenofibrates), bile acid resins (cholestyramine, colestipol), niacin and dietary interventions showed no statistically significant differences from results obtained in the control groups. Deaths from cardiovascular causes were 32 per cent lower in the omega-3 fatty acid groups than in control (placebo) groups. Statin drugs reduced cardiovascular mortality by 22 per cent and the use of bile acid resins were associated with a 30 per cent decline in cardiovascular mortality. When death from non-cardiovascular causes was considered, none of the interventions were significantly linked to reduced mortality. However, fibrates were linked to a 13 per cent increased risk of death. The effects on mortality tended to be more pronounced in longer studies and those with patients whose cardiovascular disease was well established, say the authors. Regarding n-3 fatty acids, they speculate that the reduction in mortality risk does not occur through a reduction in cholesterol but by other means, possibly antiarrhythmic, antithrombotic or anti-inflammatory effects.
The trials of n-3 fatty acids used different dietary and supplement sources; nevertheless, the
authors conclude that this study adds to the positive evidence for n-3 fatty acids. They suggest
that further trials be carried out to examine the effects of combined treatment with n-3 fatty acids
and statins.
Eating fish may lower inflammation in the blood vessels They gathered data on 1,514 men and 1,528 women aged 18 to 89, taking part in the ongoing ATTICA study into the benefits of a Mediterranean diet on heart health. Compared to those who did not eat fish, those who ate the most (10.5 ounces per week or more) had an average 33 per cent lower level of C-reactive protein, a widely-used marker for inflammation. They also had a 33 per cent lower level of interleukin-6, another inflammatory marker found in the plasma. This group had 21 per cent lower tumor necrosis factor-alpha, which affects lipid metabolism, coagulation, and insulin resistance, and 28 per cent lower serum amyloid A, a blood protein increased by inflammation. Significantly lower levels of these markers were also found in people who ate about 5 to 10 ounces of fish per week. This clear and strong inverse association between fish consumption and inflammatory markers may help explain why people who eat fish tend to have lower rates of heart disease, say the authors. The benefits remained once many risk factors were taken into account and were observed even in people with high blood pressure or diabetes, but not high cholesterol. Nevertheless, it was a cross-sectional study which did not follow people over time, so cannot prove causation.
These results support recommendations that people eat more fish, the authors write, particularly
oily fish with their high levels of omega-3 fatty acids. One or two portions per week may be
sufficient, but the fish should not be fried. In some cases, omega-3 fatty acid supplements may be
appropriate to achieve an optimal intake of 0.6 grams of omega-3 fatty acids per day.
Polyunsaturated fatty acids don’t compete over benefits Researchers studied the links between various PUFA intakes and the incidence of coronary heart disease (CHD) in 45,722 men enrolled in the Health Professionals Follow-up Study. A reliable food-frequency questionnaire was given at the start and completed every four years to determine PUFA intakes. During the 14 years of follow-up, there were 218 sudden deaths, 1,521 nonfatal myocardial infarctions (MIs) and 2,306 total CHD events (combined sudden death, other CHD deaths, and nonfatal MI) among the participants. Dietary analysis showed that both seafood-derived long-chain and plant-derived intermediate-chain n-3 PUFA intakes were linked to a reduced CHD risk, regardless of n-6 PUFA intake. Men who consumed more than 250 mg seafood-based n-3 PUFA per day had a 40-50 per cent lower risk of CHD.
The researchers also looked at the relationship between seafood-based n-3 PUFAs and plant-based n-3
PUFAs. They found that when seafood-based n-3 PUFA intake is low (less than 100 mg per day), plant-
based n-3 PUFAs are particularly effective at reducing CHD risk. For every additional 1 g of plant-based n-3
PUFA per day, MI risk was reduced by 58 per cent and total CHD risk was reduced by 47 per cent. Contrary
to previous findings, this study found no links between overall CHD risk and intake of n-6 PUFAs. The
results suggest that a modest dietary intake of seafood (250 mg, equaling around 1-2 oily fish meals a week)
may lower the risk of CHD, irrespective of n-6 PUFA intake. The authors concluded that plant sources of
PUFAs are especially important in populations with limited access to, or consumption of seafood.
Determination of omega-3 fatty acids in heart tissue Researchers at the Mid America Heart Institute now report that the EPA + DHA content of red blood cells (RBCs) almost exactly mirrors the concentration in the myocardium. Their study involved 20 heart transplant patients whose EPA + DHA level was measured in heart tissue and red blood cells. The researchers found an almost perfect correlation (r = 0.82) between the content in cardiac tissue and the content of RBCs.
In a subsequent experiment involving 25 heart transplant patients, the researchers measured EPA + DHA
in
biopsied myocardial tissue, plasma lipids, cells scraped from the cheek (buccal tissue), and red blood
cells
before and after 6 months of supplementation with 300 mg EPA + 200 mg DHA. The supplementation
resulted
in a 272% increase in EPA and a 94% increase in DHA in the heart tissue itself. The corresponding
increases in
plasma lipids, buccal tissue, and RBCs were 365% and 104%, 124% and 95%, and 279% and 84%
respectively.
The best correlation was between myocardial tissue and RBCs followed by myocardial tissue and buccal
tissue.
The researchers conclude that EPA and DHA levels in RBCs give an accurate indication of the content in
heart
cells. Buccal tissue is also a good indicator, but more cumbersome and exacting to obtain than a blood
sample.
The researchers also point out that RBC content is a good indicator of long-term intake, whereas plasma
lipids
vary depending on the food consumed on the day immediately preceding the test.
Fish oils recommended for heart disease prevention
Fish and fish oils contain long-chain polyunsaturated omega-3 fatty acids, more specifically, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). The average American diet contains only about 100-200 mg/day of EPA and DHA. The diet also contains about 1.4 grams/day of alpha- linolenic acid mainly from canola and soybean oils. Alpha-linolenic acid can be converted in the body to EPA and DHA, but not in amounts sufficient to make a significant impact. Some studies have shown that alpha-linolenic acid, on its own, may have heart-protective effects, but other studies have failed to confirm this. NOTE: Flax seed oil is a particularly rich source of alpha-linolenic acid.
The American Heart Association recommends that people increase their intake of long-chain
polyunsaturated omega-3 oils from fish or directly from fish oil supplements. Healthy people should
consume oily fish at least twice a week. Patients with heart disease should eat enough oily fish on a daily
basis to obtain about 1 gram per day of EPA and DHA combined or take a fish oil supplement providing 1
gram per day of EPA + DHA. Patients with high triglyceride levels should receive 2-4 grams/day of
EPA+DHA under the care of a physician. The reviewers point out that many fish species contain
significant amounts of methylmercury, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), dioxins, and other
environmental contaminants and therefore must be consumed in moderation, if at all, especially by
children and pregnant and lactating women. Poorer quality fish oils may also contain these contaminants,
so it is important to only supplement with highly purified, pharmaceutical grade oils.
Antiarrhythmic properties of fish oils Researchers at the universities of Chieti and Pisa recently published a review of the current “state-of-the- art” in regard to fish oils and arrhythmias. Highlights are:
Although most research, so far, has focused on the effect of fish oil on life-threatening ventricular
arrhythmias it is likely than many of the findings may also be applicable to atrial fibrillation.
Fish consumption lowers heart rate A group of European researchers now reports that regular fish consumption can lower heart rate by as much as 2 bpm. Their study included 9758 men aged 50 to 59 years from four European cities (Belfast, Lille, Strasbourg, and Toulouse). Twenty-seven per cent of the men consumed fish less than once per week, 47% consumed fish once a week, 20% twice a week, and the remaining 6% more than twice a week. The average heart rate (adjusted for age, physical activity, smoking, alcohol consumption, etc) was 67.5 bpm in men consuming fish less than once per week and 65.6 bpm in men consuming fish more than twice per week. Fish consumers also had lower triglyceride levels, lower blood pressure (both systolic and diastolic), and higher levels of beneficial HDL cholesterol than did non-consumers. The erythrocyte content of DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) in the blood was found to be inversely correlated with heart rate.
The researchers point out that there is considerable evidence that omega-3 fatty acids such as those
found in fish and fish oils stabilize the electrical activity of heart cells by elevating the action potential
threshold and prolonging the relative refractory time. There is also evidence that a high omega-3 content
of blood cells and serum cholesterol esters is associated with increased heart rate variability. A higher
heart rate variability has been associated with a decreased risk of cardiac disease and a longer
lifespan.
Fish oils benefit the heart
Recent research concludes that perhaps the most important effect of fish oils, when it comes to
preventing cardiovascular disease, is their ability to stabilize atherosclerotic plaque by reducing the
infiltration of inflammatory and immune cells (lymphocytes and macrophages) into the plaque. Heart
attacks are now believed to involve the rupture of an atherosclerotic plaque. These plaques come in two
main varieties, those with a thin, unstable fibrous cap and those with a thick, stable fibrous cap. A recent
study showed that supplementation with 1.4 grams/day of fish oil significantly reduced macrophage
infiltration and resulted in a substantial shift towards a preponderance of stable, thick-capped plaques. At
least two studies have shown that the beneficial effects of fish oils on heart health become clear after
about 2 months.
Fish oils help prevent stroke and heart attacks Researchers at the University of Southampton have just completed a clinical trial to see if fish oil supplementation would improve plaque stability and thus help prevent heart attack and stroke. Their study involved 162 patients who were awaiting carotid endarterectomy (an operation involving the removal of atherosclerotic deposits from the carotid artery feeding the brain). The patients were randomly allocated to receive a placebo, fish oil (omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid) or sunflower oil (omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acid) daily from the time they entered the study until the endarterectomy during which atherosclerotic plaque was removed for analysis. The placebo capsules contained an 80:20 blend of palm and soybean oils (a composition which closely matches that of the average UK diet); the sunflower oil capsules contained 1 gram of sunflower oil plus 1 mg of vitamin E (alpha-tocopherol); the fish oil capsules contained 1 gram of fish oil and 1 mg of vitamin E. The participants took 6 capsules daily providing a total to 3.6 grams linoleic acid (in the sunflower oil capsules) or 850 mg EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) + 500 mg of DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) in the fish oil capsules. The duration of supplementation varied between 7 and 189 days with the median being 42 days. Upon analysis of the removed plaque the researchers found that the supplemented fish oil (EPA and DHA) had been readily incorporated into the plaques and had resulted in favourable changes. Plaque from fish oil treated patients tended to have thick fibrous caps and no signs of inflammation indicating more stability. Plaques from the control and sunflower oil groups, on the other hand, tended to have thin fibrous caps and signs of inflammation indicating less stability. The number of macrophages (large scavenger cells) in the plaque of fish oil treated patients was also significantly less than the number observed in the control and sunflower oil groups.
The researchers conclude that the increased plaque stability observed in the fish oil treated patients could
explain the reduction in fatal and non-fatal heart attacks and strokes associated with an increased intake
of fish oils.
Older people benefit from fish oils The researchers found that subjects with a high phospholipid content of EPA + DHA had a 70% lower incidence of fatal heart disease than did those with a lower level (4.1% versus 3.3% of total fatty acids). Participants with a high level of ALA had a 50% reduced risk of fatal heart disease. Subjects with a high level of LA, on the other hand, had a 2.4 times higher incidence of fatal heart disease than did those with a lower level. There was no association between the levels of the fatty acids and the incidence of non- fatal heart attacks. The researchers ascribe this to the fact that EPA and DHA (and perhaps ALA) are known to prevent ventricular arrhythmias – the main factor in sudden cardiac death. Ventricular arrhythmias are not involved in non-fatal heart attacks.
The researchers conclude that their findings lend further support to the recommendation from the
American Heart Association to consume 2 fish meals (preferably fatty fish) per week. Dr. William Harris
of the University of Missouri, in commenting on the results, suggests that a combined daily intake of 1
gram of EPA + DHA is both safe and prudent, but that supplementation with fish oil capsules may be
required to achieve this goal.
Fish oils for heart health
Fish oils protect women against heart disease
Fish oils protect against sudden death
Trans-fatty acids implicated in sudden death
New risk factor for sudden death
Fish oils prevent sudden cardiac death Danish researchers now report that fish oils markedly increase heart rate variability and conclude that this is probably the explanation for their protective effect. Their study involved 291 patients who had been referred for coronary angiography because of suspected heart disease. The participants completed food questionnaires including a question about wine consumption and had their blood cell (granulocytes) and fat tissue level of eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) determined. The participants also had their heart rate variability (HRV) measured over a 24-hour period. The researchers found an excellent correlation between the reported intake of fish and fat tissue levels of EPA and DHA. They also noted a distinct association between high EPA/DHA levels and high HRV. Patients with a high wine intake also had high HRV values, but further analysis showed that these patients also had a high fish intake. When corrected for this confounding variable there was no correlation between wine consumption and HRV. There also was no correlation between the intake of beer and HRV.
The researchers conclude that high body levels of EPA and DHA can markedly reduce the risk of sudden
cardiac death and ascribe this protective effect to the increased heart rate variability associated with
increased fish or fish oil consumption.
Increased fish intake combats heart disease
Other major AHA guidelines for heart disease prevention are:
Krauss, Ronald M., et al. AHA Dietary Guidelines - Revision 2000: a statement for healthcare professionals from the Nutrition Committee of the American Heart Association. Circulation, Vol. 102, October 31, 2000, pp. 2284-99
Fish consumption reduces heart disease risk Fifty men (aged 25 to 65 years) from the fishing village and 37 men from the rural village participated in the study. They all had fasting blood samples drawn and had their food intake evaluated by 2 nutritionists using a food frequency questionnaire. The men from the fishing village consumed 8 times more fish than did the men in the rural village and as a result had much higher levels of EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid) and DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) in their blood than did the men in the rural village. The researchers observed a good correlation between fish intake and blood levels of EPA and DHA. They also found that the fishing village men had lower levels of triglycerides (28% lower) and total cholesterol (10% lower) than did the men from the inland village. Of particular note was the finding that the ratio of EPA to arachidonic acid in the blood was twice as high in the fishing village as in the rural village. A high ratio has, in other studies, been linked to a lower incidence of blood clots.
The researchers conclude that regular fish consumption is associated with higher blood levels of EPA and
DHA, lower triglyceride and cholesterol levels, and a 4 times lower mortality from coronary heart
disease.
The ultimate supplement for heart health
Fish consumption and coronary heart disease Their study involved 2738 men who were aged 50 to 69 years at the start of the study in 1970. After 20 years of follow-up 242 (22.2%) of the Finnish men, 116 (10.6%) of the Italian men, and 105 (19%) of the Dutch men had died from CHD. The researchers found no correlation between total fish consumption and CHD mortality. They also failed to confirm a correlation between the consumption of lean fish (plaice, codfish, bream, perch, pike) and the risk of dying from CHD. However, when looking at the consumption of fatty fish (mackerel, herring, eel) the researchers found a clear protective effect. Men who habitually consumed fatty fish had a 34% lower risk of dying from CHD than did men who did not eat fatty fish. This correlation held true even after adjusting for other variables commonly associated with an increased risk of death from CHD.
The researchers point out that while 15 grams of lean fish provides only about 50 mg of omega-3 fatty
acids, 15 grams of fatty fish provides about 400 mg. They suggest that the oils in fatty fish
(eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid) prevent death from CHD through their inhibition of
platelet aggregation, their antiarrhythmic properties, and their tendency to increase heart rate variability.
The researchers believe that the reason why one study found a higher mortality from CHD among Finnish
men consuming lean fish was that the fish from the area under study was heavily contaminated with
mercury.
Eat fish and live longer
Fish consumption was not associated with the risk of nonsudden death, total myocardial infarction or total
deaths from cardiovascular diseases. There was, however, a 30 per cent decrease in the overall
mortality among the men consuming fish once or more each week as compared to the men eating fish
less than once per month. The researchers speculate that fish consumption may exert its protective
effect by preventing fatal arrhythmias. They suggest that the n-3 fatty acids found in fish and shellfish
(eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid) are responsible for the antiarrhythmic properties and
point out that alpha-linolenic acid, an n-3 fatty acid found in flax oil and nuts, also has antiarrhythmic
properties. They did not investigate the benefits of fish oil supplements and purposely excluded 777
physicians from the study who were taking fish oil supplements. The researchers conclude that eating
fish once per week may substantially reduce the risk of sudden cardiac death. In an accompanying
editorial Dr. Daan Kromhout of the Dutch National Institute of Public Health concurs with this conclusion
and adds that patients already suffering from cardiac disease should be advised to eat fish twice a week.
Vegetable oils don't affect beneficial effects of fish oils Fish oils (n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids) and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (from vegetable oils) are metabolized in a similar way and n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (n-3 PUFAs) have been shown to block the conversion of linoleic acid, the major n-6 PUFA in vegetable oils, to arachidonic acid. These interactions and competitive metabolic pathways have raised concerns that the benefits of fish oil consumption may be reduced if the diet is high in n-6 PUFAs from vegetable oils.
Researchers at the Louisiana State University have just released the results of a major study aimed at
addressing these concerns. Their study involved 68 healthy men and women between the ages of 18
and 49 years. The participants consumed diets containing varying amounts of fish oils and vegetable oils
for an eight-week period. The researchers found that fish oil supplementation lowered the blood plasma
levels of triglycerides and arachidonic acid independent of the level of n-6 PUFAs in the diet. They
conclude that vegetable oil in the diet does not reduce the benefits of fish oil in lowering the risk of death
from heart disease. They also conclude that the fish oil intake required to effectively reduce triglyceride
levels is less than six grams/day and that higher intakes do not confer added benefits. The daily intake
required to affect a meaningful reduction in fibrinogen concentration (an indicator of blood clotting
tendency) is less clear; it may be as low as 1.3 grams/day or as high as 15 grams/day. Further work is
required to settle this question. [30 references]
Omega-3 fatty acids help protect against heart disease
Docosahexaenoic acid fights depression
Fish is good for you
Consuming freshwater fish may lower risk of heart disease
|

|
Additional References
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |